Strategic Governance: How Community Bank Leadership Should Choose New Board Members 

Community banking relies on relationship-building and deep local roots, meaning your board of directors should be a reflection of your community. But community bank boards are aging and stepping down. Institutions are grappling with the question of who will fill these seats, many of which have been occupied by the same pillar of the community for decades. Modern regulatory pressures, cybersecurity risks, and fintech competition mean your board can no longer be just a “friends-and-neighbors” club. Many community banks still rely on informal, legacy recruitment strategies, like appointing local business owners based solely on long-standing personal relationships. Choosing the right board member requires a deliberate, matrix-driven approach that balances local community representation with technical governance skills, strategic vision, and independent oversight. 

Step 1: Conduct a Skills & Diversity Gap Analysis  

To get the board you want, first start with the board you have. Evaluate your current board with data rather than intuition, using a formal Board Skills Matrix. First, identify skill gaps in areas key to the bank’s success, such as: 

Cybersecurity & IT: Essential for evaluating modern operational risks and vendor management.  

Regulatory & Compliance Expertise: Deep understanding of FDIC/OCC expectations, risk management, and legal standards.  

Finance, Accounting, & M&A: Strong financial acumen to chair or support the Audit Committee.  

Once you’ve identified key skill gaps to fill, evaluate the diversity of your board – but don’t let diversity become a box to check. Inviting perspectives from the cultures, demographics, and backgrounds that make up your customer base leads to stronger decisions, and ultimately, a stronger institution. Seek diversity of thought—like millennial perspectives for modern digital banking, or multicultural perspectives on your brand.  

Step 2: Strike the Right Balance Between Insiders and Outside Independents  

A healthy community bank board of directors includes a mix of insiders and outside independents. An insider is employed by the institution, a family member, or part of the ownership, whereas a true outside independent is not employed by the bank, nor a large shareholder. An outsider can, however, be a customer of the bank.  

Including true outside, independent directors can improve objectivity and oversight, particularly on committees like Audit and Compensation. On an ideal board, a 60/40 split between outsiders and insiders, respectively, is recommended. Combine functional specialists (CPAs, tech executives, attorneys) with local business or civic leaders who understand your specific market’s economic engine. However, be careful to avoid conflicts of interest. Ensure candidate selection upholds strict legal standard duties (e.g., Duty of Loyalty) and avoids potential loan/credit conflicts or overlapping executive roles. 

Step 3: Define Clear Roles, Expectations, and Time Commitments  

You wouldn’t fill a C-suite role by asking your most willing friend. Neither would you throw them into the job without so much as a job description. Yet this is often the way that board recruitment works at community banks. Instead, treat board recruitment with the same rigor as an executive hire by creating a written position overview and setting explicit expectations early. Discuss expectations like active participation in audit, loan, risk, or ALCO committees; meeting attendance; strategic planning involvement; annual evaluations; and willingness to offer constructive, collegial dissent rather than functioning as a rubber stamp. Just like bank staff, directors should also commit to continuous learning and ongoing education. Offer – and even require – specialized certifications or regulatory updates.  

Step 4: Build a Continuous Talent Pipeline  

As the same directors hold onto their seats year after year, it can be tempting to redirect focus from the board to seemingly more pressing matters. Until, that is, one steps down and you’re left scrambling to replace him or her. Don’t wait until a long-serving director retires or hits age limits to start searching. Instead, build a talent pipeline for board seats just like you would for key staff positions. Start your search by keeping an eye on other local boards and networks. Use regional or advisory boards as a training ground to evaluate potential main-board candidates, and look beyond traditional circles to regional technology hubs, accounting firms, and local business organizations. But don’t make this search a solitary or informal endeavor; integrate board recruitment directly into your bank’s annual strategic planning cycle.   

A community bank’s board of directors is one of its most critical strategic assets, and the decision to choose your next board member shapes your bank’s direction for the next decade. 

No bank can afford to phone in the decision of who fills the next open seat. Moving from informal recruitment to a skill-based, forward-looking process ensures long-term stability and growth.